Thursday, August 23, 2007

and you put the load right on me

I tend to be a bit hesitant in writing about body issues/weight issues. There are just too many overlapping and/or conflicting arguments tied up in the matter, from public health concerns to one's personal sense of self worth to the predatory market forces that offer unrealistic standards while selling junk food and dubious weight loss plans. The end result is a veritable key party of strange bedfellows, and no matter how many qualifiers or caveats I hedge my opinions with, it still feels like I'm reaching blind into a barrel of razor blades. No one should feel compelled to conform to an unobtainable ideal at the expense of their own sense of well being. That said, pulling a semi trailer with subcompact sporting a 4-cylinder is going to have dire consequences in the long run, especially when the most readily available fuel is prone to clogging the feed lines.

Here's an examination of body image issues, courtesy of Date With Debbi #15 (May-June 1971):

Debbi's friend Lylia is overweight. We know this because she is always shown either stuffing food into her face or participating in some tired old "fat" gag. See? She broke the scale because she's not wasp-waistedly skinny! Why she might even weight over 150 pounds! Call the circus!

Lylia has a crush on Henry, the George Lindsey-esque fellow who works at the gas station. She feels unfit to approach him because of her weight, overlooking the fact that a man who has free-floating eyebrows and who wears a felt crown to work should be the last person to judge someone based on appearances.

Now, I'm no psychiatrist, but it's been my experience that the kind of compulsive, binge eating behavior Lylia is depicted as having is often a symptom of an underlying sense of unhappiness, which can encompass any number of traumas large or small. To treat the manifestation without examining the cause seems rather irresponsible, especially considering the motivating factor in Lylia's desire to lose weight is a desire to be loved. It's sad if you think about it....

...but not so much that it can't be mined for some incredibly demeaning humor. Remember, kids, in the world of teen humor comics "fat" equals "will repudiate any personal dignity for the sake of a hot dog."

Twelve panels and a dozen similarly depressing gags later, Debbi has managed to reshape Lylia into a more socially acceptable size zero package and sends her off to woo the grease monkey of her dreams. Mission accomplished, right?

That ungrateful little witch! How dare she exhibit a newfound confidence about herself! (Actually, the "booking every boy in town for a date" bit would suggest that, as I mentioned before, Lylia's binge-eating problem had roots in personal issues such a lack of self-worth, which has now manifested itself in the social butterfly's need for external validation.)

Don't worry, Debbi has a plan to take care of that...

I have read many, many comics in my three and a half decades on this planet, and that has to be the cruelest, most sadistic ending to a story I've ever come across...and that's counting that 1950's EC horror story where the evil fireman slides down a giant razor blade put in place of the station's firepole.

As flies to wanton boys, are we to the gods, --They kill us for their sport. - Gloucester, King Lear (Act IV, Scene i)

The Band - The Weight (from Music From Big Pink, 1968) - One of those trancendental songs that just carries you away and takes you to someplace better for an all too brief time -- so of course it would end up being used in a commercial for cell phones.

Medium Medium - Hungry, So Angry (from a 1981 single; collected on Hungry, So Angry, 2001) - Postpunk funk with slap bass and crossover disco appeal.

1 comments:

SallyP said...

Brrrr...that's cold!