Tuesday, February 13, 2007

blazing noggins and other childhood pursuits

'Stormy's so emo.
It’s time to dip down once again into the Well of Nerdity; its waters possessing the Lethe-like power to make folks forget all semblance of rationality or proportionality.

The comic fans among my readers should be acquainted with the concept of “fan entitlement,” the excessive proprietary interest fans take in their fictional characters of choice, and frequently manifested as online rantings of the shrillest sort should official plot developments deviate from their personal Platonic ideals. In saner circles of fandom, fan entitlement arguments are usually dismissed out of hand (a la Godwin’s Law), although I can occasionally muster up an iota of sympathy for the aggrieved ones’ pain, if not their methodology.

Serial entertainment, such superhero comics or soap operas, depends on a sense of continuity of character, rather than plots (which will inevitable be recycled over time), to retain its audience’s attention. When someone buys a ticket to a Bond film, one expects to see the adventures of a suave, British spy and not, say, a Romanian cyborg with a eye that shoots laser beams. Tweaks and other minor refinements are to be expected in order to keep things fresh over the long haul, but it is assumed that the core concept will remain immutable.

Eventually, though, this steady state runs up against the business version of the Second Law of Thermodynamics: franchise entropy and its ubiquitous handmaiden, diminishing returns. It’s a bigger problem in superhero comics than other forms of media, because the graying audience for that material has gotten smaller over time, and currently lacks the feeder markets by which to effectively bring in new readers.

So, in order to reignite interest and spark sales, periodic shake ups -- individual reboots or line-wide events -- have become the solution of choice. Characters live, characters die, some characters will be changed forever, and all that jazz. It’s the idea of continuous revolution as applied to the spandex set, and in the midst of all these goings-on, it’s inevitable that certain fans’ toes will get stepped on. When you’ve lived (and read comics) for as long as I’ve had, it’s not so difficult to look at these turns of the wheel from a metaphysical, fatalist frame of reference; today’s massive changes are tomorrow’s deletions.

Some fans, however, can’t (or won’t) bring themselves to look at the big picture where entertainment and commerce intersect, and treat each change as a personal affront. Even worse, for every soul who has a sincere fondness for “Character X,” there are dozens of others with little sense of history of or personal attachment to Character X who hop on the fan entitlement bandwagon with a variety of sharp implements to grind at the ready.

It’s much ado about nothing, this staking of one’s self to the vicissitudes of disposable entertainment, and, heck, as it has been said many times, the changes don’t invalidate the entertainment value of the original stories…although that value might have certain unconsidered qualifiers.

Firestorm, “The Nuclear Man,” was the brainchild of writer Gerry Conway and artist Al Milgrom. The character was the superheroic gestalt of high school jock Ronnie Raymond and physicist Martin Stein, who were caught in a nuclear accident and via the power of “fusion” gained the power to combine into a single superbeing with Ronnie in the driver’s seat and Stein acting as a disembodied mentor. He debuted in his own title in 1978, which lasted five issues before getting axed during the corporate retrenchment dubbed the “DC Implosion”.

Conway brought the character back as the member of the Justice League (the last member to join the “Satellite Era” incarnation of the team) and as a back up feature in the Flash’s monthly series. He was given his own solo title again, The Fury of Firestorm, in 1982 featuring artwork by Pat Broderick (on and off) for the first year and a half or so.

In the late 80’s, writer John Ostrander took the title in a bizarre direction involving Cold War politics and Swamp Thing-inspired ideas about elemental beings. After the title folded in 1990, the character spent a number of years in the b-lister wilderness before being killed off during Identity Crisis and replaced with a newer version of the character.

I got Fury of Firestorm #6 in a trade with a friend when I was eleven years old, which just the right age level for the material. The character’s excessively complicated origin/power/costume and, most importantly, his sense of “newness” was just what my young fanboy self was looking for. This was around the time I started to have the means to follow monthly titles, rather than rely on parent-purchased back issues from flea markets, and I made the effort to follow the series up until Ostrander took the title in a new direction.

I still have the run in one of my back issue boxes, the gaps having been filled during my back issue buying frenzy in the mid-90’s, While I still enjoy reading them, I’ve come to realize that my enjoyment is associative in nature. If I had come into possession of the comics this morning, or shot up with a nostalgia-blocking neurochemical before reading them, I’d consider the stories mediocre at best, even with my legendary tolerance for what laymen call “crap.”

Conway’s Firestorm stories are painfully obvious reworkings of his work on Marvel’s Spider-Man books, with the requisite doses of youthful angst and the genre equivalent of “real life problems.” His attempts to tweak the old formula, such as making Ronnie Raymond a jock whose high school nemesis is a nerd, are transparent and laughable. It’s also unclear whether he grasped the full implications of the gestalt nature of Firestorm’s superheroic identity, opening up a whole world of interesting subtexts and outright creepiness. (Then there’s the revelation that Sandy Duncan was the original drummer for The Clash…)

Yet I still love those comics, because they remind me of bike riding with my friends down the dirt tracks that used to crisscross North Woburn, of four-player games of Warlords on the Atari 2600, of picnic table speculations about Revenge of the Jedi, and of listening to “Mr. Roboto” and “Come on Eileen” on the local Top 40 radio station. No retcons, reboots, or shock value deaths will change that. Affection doesn’t have to be an all or nothing proposition. When it comes to comics fandom, the world would be a saner place if it wasn’t.

John Foxx – Fusion/Fission (from The Garden, 1981) – Foxx was the original frontman for Ultravox, and you can hear traces of that band’s sound, with a slightly darker tone, on this track.

+/- - Setting Your Head on Fire (from Self-Titled Long Playing Debut Album, 2002) – I’m torn on this one. It’s a very nice bit of indie pop with some electronic elements, yet the band’s “clever” use of symbols for a name irritates the hell out of me and makes it very hard to label their mp3 files and run web searches (as + and – are often used as search qualifiers).

Spice Girls – 2 Become 1 (from Spice, 1996) – For more Spice-y thoughts, check out Tim O’Neil’s ruminations regarding ten years on a Spice World.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Ho-leeee crap. I haven't thought about Firestorm since 1984. Thanks for the temporal whiplash.

bitterandrew said...

You're welcome! Stay tuned for my three-week retrospective of Arion: Lord of Atlantis...

Agoblinist said...

I have been in school waaaay to long. As I read I couldn't help thinking, "That's a fine argument for precedence and the common law".....someone....help.....

bitterandrew said...

Except there's a degree of difference between consensual and organic legal "house rules" and some guy who throws online hissy fits about a furry fan-favorite Teen Titans character got gakked in a recent crossover.

A small difference, but a difference none the less...